Baby, I'm so into you
But there's been somethin', I'm real confused
Baby, you're shuttin' me down, oh
Can't tell you new things, your finger's on my mouth
"Stay mysterious for me"
My eyebrow's jumpin', it's so hard to see
Why you don't want to know more
Isn't it a thing for couples to explore?

You like me shady, you don't want deets
I guess you like it as a mystique
Oh-oh-oh, shady, doesn't feel alright
Baby, all I'd tell you is the films I like

Oh-oh-ho-oh-oh

Told me that you're into me
Know zilch about me, that shouldn't be
Told me I'm the one for you, oh
I might be keepin' bad secrets from you
Sure, I'm cute, there should be more
Than the nebulousness of a vague allure

You like me shady, you don't want deets
"Don't talk, just hide it"? What, all of me?
Oh-oh-oh, shady, doesn't feel alright
Baby, all I'd say is what foods I don't like

Shady with zero deets
Can't even type it down in a tweet
Shady, doesn't feel alright
Know my shape, that's enough? Lies

You like me shady (you like me shady, baby)
No, I don't like it so I'll just leave
Oh-oh-oh, shady (this doesn't feel alright)
Baby, mysteries shouldn't last one's whole life (oh-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh)
You like me shady (you like me shady, baby)
Yeah-eah-hea-eah-eah-eah, yeah
Oh-oh-oh, shady (you like me), doesn't feel alright
Baby, I can't keep ev'rything a surprise
Baby, you'll learn nothin' 'cause this is goodbye